- A new review determined that highly engineered consumables could be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
- The study authors found that these foods are formulated to boost reward and accelerate the delivery of reinforcing components.
- The habit-forming quality of these foods means they drive uncontrollable eating and hinder natural hunger cues.
- The review authors propose that ultraprocessed foods could be subject to regulations similar to those for cigarettes.
Currently, there is no single standardized definition of ultraprocessed foods. Some people describe them as foods that include additives you are unlikely to have in a home kitchen, for instance stabilizers and additives.
Numerous experts rely on the NOVA system to define ultraprocessed foods. This refers to products that are “formulations of components, primarily of manufacturing origin, typically created by a series of industrial techniques and methods.”
A recent review featured in The Millbank Quarterly suggested that ultraprocessed foods could be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
“I concur with these findings, as UPFs are specifically engineered to be highly appealing to most individuals,” stated a bariatric surgeon not affiliated with the research.
Data from last year suggests that over 73% of the food supply in the United States is classified as highly processed.
“Tobacco and ultraprocessed foods are not just whole foods but highly engineered consumable products created purposely to increase physical and mental reinforcement and compulsive consumption,” wrote the new study’s authors.
Can UPFs Addictive?
The paper synthesized findings from substance use, historical health policy, and dietary science to highlight sensory and structural features that increase the reinforcing potential of both tobacco and UPFs.
“It’s not all people is ‘hooked’ to such products, but for a significant portion, they trigger typical addiction-like patterns: intense desires, loss of control, and continued use even with harmful consequences,” said a preventive cardiology dietitian.
“These foods are deliberately engineered with refined carbs, extra oils, sodium, and flavor enhancers to maximize reward and ongoing intake, and the food sector uses aggressive marketing tactics, particularly aimed at young people,” she added.
The researchers analyzed several important factors:
- delivery speed
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be irresistibly good
- perfecting the amount
- environmental ubiquity
- deceptive reformulation, or “wellness branding”
The study concluded that, similar to tobacco, UPFs are carefully calibrated to deliver the optimal amount of sweetness.
“Processed carbs trigger the feel-good chemical release through the a key neural pathway, while fats achieve this via fat detection in the gut,” the authors explained.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with significant amounts of processed carbs and extra oils are some of the most strongly reinforcing substances in the contemporary food supply. Importantly this processed carb and fat mix is rarely found in nature.”
The way these foods quickly deliver “feel-good” chemicals to the brain renders them likely habit-forming, in a comparable way to cigarettes.
The review noted that while tobacco are designed to provide the addictive compound quickly, UPFs are formulated to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they usually have little to no dietary fiber. This allows for the body to metabolize fat and sugar faster.
The researchers also explain that ultraprocessed foods provide intentional flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that dissolve easily. This all helps to trigger increased pleasure signals and encourages individuals to eat more.
‘Wellness Branding’ in Cigarettes, Ultraprocessed Foods
Based on the analysis, both the cigarette and food sectors have historically employed a tactic called “health washing.”
This refers to where products are marketed and altered to generate an perception of less danger while maintaining the core of their properties.
Health washing in the tobacco industry gained traction in the 1950s with the introduction of filters on smokes.
They were marketed as protective innovations that would trap harmful substances before they entered the respiratory system. In reality, filters provide little meaningful benefit.
However, people typically adapted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which offset any decrease in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has taken a similar strategy. It employs packaging claims like “reduced fat” or “sugar-free” to promote ultraprocessed foods.
However, these foods often retain the same highly reinforcing ingredient combinations. The issue is that these reformulations present a superficial appearance of wellness while the product’s habit-forming nature and metabolic harms remain intact.
Ought UPFs Be Regulated?
The researchers stated at the conclusion of their paper that food and tobacco are not the same thing.
Still, they cautioned that some ultraprocessed foods act like engineered consumables rather than real nourishment. They proposed that health regulations should reflect this reality.
“Cigarettes offers a warning, and smoking regulations provides a source of potential,” the authors stated.
Because of regulations, cigarette use rates in the United States have declined and have “reshaped public perception of smoking and diminished trust in the sector.”
“It is my opinion greater awareness regarding the harmful effects of UPFs is essential to reduce general consumption and enhance public health. The strategies used to reduce cigarette consumption have been effective and could be a helpful blueprint for ultra-processed foods as well,” said one specialist.
“It is not my view ultraprocessed foods should be regulated exactly like cigarettes, but they do warrant more robust, tobacco-inspired policies: advertising limits, obvious front-of-package labeling, tighter rules on health claims, and limits in schools or medical facilities,” noted another dietitian.
The authors pointed out to people that minimally processed and whole foods have supported human health for thousands of years.